Skip to content
Explore the British Classic Collective, a community for vin…

Should the Blacksmith Has a Countless Detractors, Then I Am One of Them.

Upon learning that Clint from the beloved farming sim was revealed as one of the two marriage candidates in the forthcoming version 1.7, I exclaimed incredulously, “Him?!” The news consumed me for hours afterward — if Clint has a legion of critics (and he does), I am one of them; were he to have no enemies, it means I've departed this earthly realm. Yet, with some reflection, I’ve come to see that maybe this is precisely the intent — there is no character in more dire need of redemption than Clint.

The Root of the Ire

Clint has drawn a lot of ire for a long time, primarily because of his obsession with Emily, another marriage candidate. During his early cutscenes, he asks the player for their advice on women, then behaves with painful awkwardness in front of Emily, as she serves him in the saloon, only to moan to the player that he’s “finished.” He frequently comes off as defeatist, desperate, and borderline creepy — to many, he feels like a classic “nice guy” who gets angry at even the slightest perceived rejection.

A Widespread Reaction

My reaction to this part of the 1.7 update was far from unique. Players have voiced a myriad of complaints, disappointment over who should've been chosen instead, and countless memes since the news dropped. One social media user remarked, “Picture finishing the worst shift at work and finding out Clint is now someone you can marry in Stardew Valley.”

A Glimmer of Hope

However, part of the conversation on the matter offers a brighter perspective and — as much as I hate to admit it — has raised some valid arguments. Several players have compared the idea of Clint’s redemption to that of Haley. She is notoriously rude initially, but warms up through friendship, a process some have referred to as “improving Haley so she sucks less as a person.” Clint possesses much that identical capacity, but with a crucial distinction: he gives a lot of players the ick.

Screenshot: ConcernedApe

The Uneasy Feeling

I’ve personally always found Haley’s initial unpleasantness easier to stomach than Clint’s unrequited fixation with a woman who isn't interested, and numerous fans appear to share that sentiment. It's difficult to pinpoint exactly the reason — maybe it's simply a situation many fans can identify with, giving them a stronger gut response to Clint. This ick factor Clint possesses undeniably presents an extra wrinkle in him being seen as an desirable marriage candidate, but that might be just another reason the character is in dire need of a turnaround.

A Hint of Understanding

I will admit that, despite how often I’ve shouted about how much Clint needs to stop being weird, he does inspire a degree of sympathy. Perhaps not when the notorious scene in the bushes, but overall, he comes across as a melancholy, isolated man. A fan wrote, “He is a man yearning for someone who will choose him back, and this is what being romanceable offers him.”

A Role for Redemption

The blacksmith's upcoming romance path may not be for all types of Stardew Valley fan, but it serves a purpose. However skeptical I am that I could ever consider him as spouse material, the game's creator is a wonderful writer with a knack for giving depth to all the residents of the valley. Similar to past updates, the new version appears as a substantial content drop with a lot of love behind it, and his character arc is unlikely to be being done flippantly. Perhaps with Clint’s new romance future, fans can finally set aside their disdain for him aside and redirect it where it truly belongs — toward Pierre.

The writer

Alexandra Castro

Eleanor Hartfield is a classic car journalist and historian with a passion for British motoring heritage.

British Classic Collective

Type to search articles.